1. Sports

Discuss in my forum

Ranking the 2011-12 Free Agent Starting Pitchers

A look at the free agent starting pitchers before the 2012 season

By , About.com Guide

Updated February 16, 2012

A solid group of starters hits the free agent market this season, several with prime years remaining. As always, picking pitchers is a tough business, but it's a good year to restock arms.

A look at the top 10:

1. C.J. Wilson: The ace of the two-time AL champs, a lefty to boot, will get the biggest deal of the offseason among the pitchers, even as he went 0-3 in the playoffs for Texas. Look for the Yankees and Rangers to get involved in a bidding war. In his two years as a starter, he's averaged 15.5 wins and has an ERA in the low 3s. The Yankees will be able to afford him a little more, but will the way the season ended bring Wilson back to Arlington?

2. Mark Buehrle: Not the big-splash kind of free agent, but at age 33 (and left-handed), he's a proven veteran winner. He's won exactly 13 games in each of the last three years and he gives up his share of hits and homers, but his ERA was a solid 3.59 in 2011. He's not a great fantasy baseball option (strikeouts aren't his forte), but I bet he'd be just fine in the rotation of a contender.

3. Edwin Jackson: Like Buehrle, he's a guy on this list who has thrown a no-hitter in his career. But the reason he's bounced around is walks - he gives up a lot of them. That keeps him from being an elite option. But after going 5-2 with a 3.58 ERA in 12 starts with St. Louis, he'll have plenty of suitors.

4. Hiroki Kuroda: The Japanese right-hander was 41-46 in four years with the Dodgers, but with a very solid 3.45 ERA. He made $11.7 million last season, however, and in this market shouldn't expect a raise. At least not a big one. He'll turn 37 over the winter.

5. Roy Oswalt: A bigger name than some ranked higher on this list, but he's had durability issues and is be an "old" 34. A veteran of 2,154 innings, he went 9-10 last season. But that sparkling career ERA is still 3.21, and he was a two-time 20-game winner in his 20s. Not the strikeout pitcher he once was, but he'll make an impact somewhere.

6. Aaron Harang: The former NL strikeout champ had a nice season in the pitching-friendly confines of Petco Park, bouncing back from three consecutive losing seasons to go 14-7 with a 3.64 ERA for the Padres, lowering his ERA by 1.68 points. He's back on the free agent market and looking for a raise from his $5 million salary last season as he declined a $5M option.

7. Paul Maholm: Who is he? A decent pitcher on what has been a really bad team. Maholm, 29, is a career Pittsburgh Pirate, which means his 53-73 career record might be deceiving. He had a 3.66 ERA last season and isn't a strikeout pitcher, but for a team looking for a decent No. 4, he could pay off. A change of scenery could do him good.

8. Javier Vazquez: All he does is throw about 200 solid innings every year, but Yankees fans will remember him as a bust in 2010, the one year he didn't. He went 13-11 with a 3.69 ERA for the Marlins at age 34 in 2011. He was 5-0 with a 0.71 ERA in September. But he has hinted at retirement.

9. Bruce Chen: Was the ace of the Royals this past season, which is sad considering the young talent that Kansas City has tried to stockpile. He went 12-8 with a 3.77 ERA, and as a lefty at age 34, he'll garner some interest.

10. Chris Capuano: Another "who-is-he" in the Maholm mode, but went 11-12 with a 4.55 ERA as an innings-eater with the Mets after some so-so years in Milwaukee, bouncing around their system. Not a power guy, but a team looking to see if he's a late bloomer as a crafty lefty will give him a shot.

Others worth a look: Erik Bedard, Bartolo Colon, Jason Marquis, Chien-Ming Wang, Freddy Garcia, Rich Harden.

Ages are as of Opening Day 2012.

Free Agent Starting Pitchers

Name Age 2011 team 2011 stats 2012 team Contract
Erik Bedard 33 Red Sox 5-9, 3.62 ERA Pirates 1 yr, $4.5M
Mark Buehrle 33 White Sox 13-9, 3.59 ERA Marlins 4 yrs, $58M
Chris Capuano 33 Mets 11-12, 4.55 ERA Dodgers 2 yrs, $10M
Bruce Chen 34 Royals 12-8, 3.77 ERA Royals 2 yr, $9M
Bartolo Colon 38 Yankees 8-10, 4.00 ERA A's 1 yr, $2M
Aaron Cook 33 Rockies 3-10, 6.03 ERA Red Sox 1 yr, $1.5M
Kyle Davies 28 Royals 1-9, 6.75 ERA Blue Jays minors
Doug Davis 36 Cubs 1-7, 6.50 ERA White Sox minors
Justin Duchscherer 34 A's Injured   not signed
Zach Duke 28 D'backs 3-4, 4.93 ERA Astros minors
Jeff Francis 31 Royals 6-16, 4.82 ERA Reds minors
Armando Galarraga 30 D'backs 3-4, 5.91 ERA Orioles minors
Freddy Garcia 35 Yankees 12-8, 3.62 ERA Yankees 1 yr, $4M
Jon Garland 32 Dodgers 1-5, 4.33 ERA Indians minors
Aaron Harang 33 Padres 14-7, 3.64 ERA Dodgers 2 yrs, $12M
Rich Harden 30 A's 4-4, 5.12 ERA   not signed
Livan Hernandez 37 Nationals 8-13, 4.47 ERA Astros minors
Edwin Jackson 28 Cardinals 12-9, 3.79 ERA Nationals 1 yr, $11M
Kenshin Kawakami 36 Braves 1-10, 5.15 ERA Japan
Hiroki Kuroda 37 Dodgers 13-16, 3.07 ERA Yankees 1 yr, $10M
Rodrigo Lopez 36 Cubs 6-6, 4.42 ERA Cubs minors
Paul Maholm 29 Pirates 6-14, 3.66 ERA Cubs 1 yr, $4.75M
Jason Marquis 33 D'backs 8-6, 4.43 ERA Twins 1 yr, $3M
Kevin Milwood 37 Rockies 4-3, 3.98 ERA Mariners minors
Roy Oswalt 34 Phillies 9-10, 3.69 ERA   not signed
Brad Penny 33 Tigers 11-11, 5.30 ERA Japan 1 yr, $3M
Oliver Perez 30 Nationals minors Mariners minors
Joel Pineiro 33 Angels 7-7, 5.13 ERA Phillies minors
Mitch Talbot 28 Indians 2-6, 6.64 ERA Korea 1 yr, $300,000
Javier Vazquez 35 Marlins 13-11, 3.69 ERA Retired
Tsuyoshi Wada 31 Japan 16-5, 1.51 ERA Orioles 2 yrs, $8.15M
Tim Wakefield 45 Red Sox 7-8, 5.12 ERA   not signed
Chien-Ming Wang 32 Nationals 4-3, 4.04 ERA Nationals 1 yr, $4M
Brandon Webb 32 Rangers Injured   not signed
Dontrelle Willis 30 Reds 1-6, 5.00 ERA Phillies 1 yr, $1M
C.J. Wilson 31 Rangers 16-7, 2.94 ERA Angels 5 yrs, $77.5M
Chris Young 32 Mets 1-0, 1.88 ERA   not signed

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.