1. Home
  2. Sports
  3. Baseball

2008 Fantasy Baseball Rankings - Most Overrated Players

By Scott Kendrick, About.com

8 of 10

Most overrated fantasy outfielders

Adam Dunn of the Reds reacts to a called strike during an Aug. 1, 2007 game in Washington.

Greg Fiume/Getty Images

Carl Crawford, Rays

Average position ranking on other popular fantasy baseball sites: 3

Why he's liked: He's Willie Gault in spikes. In his five full seasons, Crawford has stolen 268 bases and batted .299.

Why you should be wary: Don't misinterpret this: Crawford is a very good player. But I don't understand why seemingly everyone would select him over Magglio Ordonez, who did everything last season - .363 average, 28 homers, 139 RBI, 117 runs, .434 on-base percentage - except steal a lot of bases. Crawford has a low OBP for a leadoff hitter (.331 career) and he doesn't hit for power or score the amount of runs you might think (an average of 93 the last five years).

Juan Pierre, Dodgers

Average position ranking on other popular fantasy baseball sites: 30

Why he's liked: Do we even have to tell you? One stat and one stat only: A combined 179 steals the last three seasons.

Why you should be wary: Why he would be anything more than a fourth outfielder in fantasy is beyond me. In that three-season span, Pierre has averaged two homers, 43 RBI, 93 runs and batted .287.

Adam Dunn, Reds

Average position ranking on other popular fantasy baseball sites: 19

Why he's liked: Finally, the anti-Crawford. Dunn is all pop and no sizzle. In the last four seasons, his home run and RBI totals read like this: 46-40-40-40 and 102-101-92-106.

Why you should be wary: He's a .248 career batter who is a liability in points leagues that penalize players for strikeouts. His strikeout totals from the last four seasons are every bit as impressive as his power numbers: 195-168-194-165.

Explore Baseball

About.com Special Features

Learn to Pitch

Strike out the competition with these step-by-step pictorials. More >

Introduction to Pilates

Learning Pilates fundamentals can help you get the most out of your exercise regime. More >

  1. Home
  2. Sports
  3. Baseball
  4. Fantasy Baseball
  5. Fantasy Baseball Tips
  6. 2008 Fantasy Coverage
  7. 2008 Fantasy Baseball Rankings - Most Overrated Players In Fantasy Baseball

©2009 About.com, a part of The New York Times Company.

All rights reserved.